THANK YOU KAYLIA!!!! people are telling me that he whispering to her....they made me think i was depth! and yes james is the sexest! theres no getting past that.

I first saw this movie in the theater, and then read the heartbreaking story by Ian McEwan. Not sure why, but It has stayed with me for months and months! The director and screenwriter did a marvelous job. The movie is superb on every level. I've bought the DVD and have watched it several times since. The era, the childhood friendship turned into love, just really resonate. How many other promising lives have been cut off like that because of war? It should be a classic. Love that James McEvoy too, gotta love those Scotsmen....

expiacion es una pelicula preciosa, una de las mejores que he visto. Hacia mucho tiempo que no llorava tanto con una pelicula. nunca pense que una pelicula pudiera ser tan perfecta y maravillosa como es Expiacion (Atonement).
una perfecta historia, unos perfectos protagonistas, una magnifica direccion i sobreodo una commovedora banda sonora que llega asta el fondo del corazon. cuando salga la pelicula aqui en españa voy a ser el primero que se la va a comprar. los premios oscar estubieron amañados, como pudo ganar no es pais para viejos con lo fea que es, tenia que ganar Expiación, la mejor pelicula de este año y de muchos otros.
Una gran admiradora que os quiere:

Sisi Love de Galen

Great movie, but the sad ending will haunt me forever.

The movie was great.. Not what I was expecting it to be but turned into something much more. The movie isn't about a love story which was it's initial let-on but rather the telling of truths... such as a the name "atonement". The reason why most people felt left in the dark was due to there not being a let on as to what the people thought during their actions and contemplations.. It is a true way of telling a story.. no one will ever know what dialogue you have in your mind during any action. Hence the reason why Bryonne didn't make anything up.. Remember this is her story of her wrong doings not the story of two lovers. It is a very true way of novel-to-screen.. We are allowed to think what they must feel during their tryst allowing to put our emotions in place. The ending was horribly sad but again.. this is her atonement.. her way of saying out loud finally what she did wrong before she loses the ability to say it.. Its obvious that nothing will be "undone" by her words. While most people would never admit such a wrong doing especially since she had ample time to take it back and didn't and after the death of C and Robbie's death nothing could be done about it.. she finally admits and says her peace with herself... great story.

May I say
I would like to kill Briony
and danny.

Very sory for my post.

First rate. Enjoy!

Oh my goodness. This movie was amazing and I shall buy it and watch it over and over again. I have recommended it to all of my friends, and they have absolutley adored it. I bought the book immediatly after I saw the movie, and It has been just as good. I wich I could of had the excitement of seeing it intheatres, but instead rented it. Either way, I had the most excitiment than I have ever had with any other movie. Pride and Prejudice was GREAT! And the director did just as an amazing job on this!! I love this movie!!!

Excellent film, but why do the historical reaearchers always let them down! The scene with James McAvoy in the bath early in the film has an aircraft pictured through the skylight, an R.A.F. bomber. The only problem is that the first heavy R.A.F. bomber was the Short Stirling, which wasn't commisioned by the Air Staff until 1936 and the first protype flew in 1939, but this scene was supposed to be in 1935. Tedious I know, but these people get paid a fortune and still can't get it right.

Everything about this movie was amazing. I saw it in the theater and I have bought it and watched it twice more. It never gets old, and I feel a million emotions every time. Splendid acting! Great music! And the beauty of the film is wonderous.

As a woman over fifty, I am embarressed to admit that I am now in love with a 28 year old man. James McAvoy is delicious!

it was a good movie, i cried, but i did not get attached to Cecilia's character, I didn't really feel too sorry for her, there should have been more character development for her.

I watched Atonement this weekend and enjoyed it.
I definitely enjoyed the movie,even if there is no happy ending. It is bit confusing at first till you realize you are seeing different perspectives. A young girl with a crush is jealous of her older sister who has the attention of the man she is crushing on. She realizes he sees her as only a child, and does not even see how she feels about him. She may misunderstand some of what is happening, but she understands he prefers her sister, and she gets even with them both. You really need to pay attention because of the way it skips back and forth with flashbacks. I caught more things the second time I watched the movie, and more after watching the special features.She knows it is not him who attacked her cousin, in fact I don't even think her cousin was raped, I think she only acted that way because they were caught in the act, and she protected her
"attacker" by not telling the truth herself, and allowing Briony to lie about Robbie. Because Robbie was not the same class as they were, he would be less likely to be believed. Her attacker, Leon's friend Paul was wealthy, and you could tell there was an attraction between them, and she was flirting with him.

I watched the movie tonight. I really wanted to like it, but it was just all over the place and somewhat hard to follow at times. I too felt that scenes were left out, though I do see where the director wanted to go, I felt he never really got there. I have to get the book, I need closure (in a sense)!!

Based on the Ian McEwan bestseller of the same name, "Atonement" should not be mistaken as a romance. It is about the writer, not the lovers (from whom we are doubly removed). In maintaining that perspective, and re-enforcing it at the end, the film wasn’t the improvement it could have been. Yet "Atonement" is an achievement in fimmaking; the screenwriter, director, cinematographer, art director, and costume designer, have together painted a beautiful, accurate portrait of both the novel and the era in which it takes place. Unfortunately, portraits aren’t anything more than visual. "Atonement" is no exception. It climaxes early, and forgoes a great deal of plot in favour of ages of extended resolution. It is layered with more with sweeping scores - and ticking clocks - than with dialogue. And while the characters seem to do a lot of contemplating during their silences (we see strong performances from all the actors), they are too introverted to share much of their thoughts; the result is an overall aloofness about the picture that can lead us, too, to become detached.

Although this film doesn't end the way most would like, it is a true reflection of the way most couples ended in this time period. I would like to imagine that we all experience a love like C's a Robbie's, however, the theme of Bryannie's play as a child exposes that most of us love or marry for simplicity or in my words, " safety". I was deeply saddened by the ending, not because I was wrapped up in the characters, but becuase I know that many lost the ones they DEEPLY loved, or each other, despite the child's selfish acts. Also, a 10 year old in the 1930's who witnesses acts or innuendos of the sexual nature would most definetly be traumatized, not understanding why it might turn a woman on to be talked to in such a way, whereas in the present, a 10 year old most likely wouldn't be phased, as nearly all households have been exposed to or use this type or language. Personally, I think Bryannie saw a crime and not a passionate moment between Cecilia and Robbie, and what started off as a confession of "truth" turned into revenge for her sister, not Lola. What "good" sister would let her sibling be with a "sex monster". As Brynannie grew in maturity, with her flashbacks, I think the recognization of what she thought was a love between herself and Robbie, was really an infatuation on her behalf, as her body language suggested when she invited Robbie to her play. There is one thing that we all must take away from this film, whether we liked it or not, and that is to love a true love, and never lose sight of what our time on Earth is really about, because life is short, and we all have a death clock ticking.

There wasn't enough character development or love development in the movie. If I had read the book first I might already have an attachment to the characters and feel hopeful that they would end up together, but since I didn't read the book and the movie didn't make me fall in love with the characters it was quite boring to watch. The only reason it wasn't a waste of 2 hours was because I was able to warn others to just buy the book and skip the movie.

I can't believe someone like Billy has wasted so much of his time writing about a movie he does not like. He cannot spell to save his life, nor does he have any passion for life. This movie had a message that seems to have surpassed Billy's small brainwaves. It's just too bad that people can't watch a movie like it or dislike it and move on. Their is enough bitterness in this world.

I thought the movie was wonderful, everything was very thought out.

I loved this book and the writing and diction was incredible, but when I saw the movie (although the acting on James McAvoy's part was incredible) I was extremely disappointed. The ending was completely altered, important pieces were missing, and the entire thing was all too dramatic. The drama involved in the plot is so much more poignant with Ian McEwan's simplicity and poise. The book was extremely descriptive, so there was not much room for inventiveness on the part of the directors, and yet they still messed it up...that's the only thing truly amazing about this movie. Out of five stars? I'd give it 1.

You people need to get out more. Seriously. The only thing tragic about Atonement is the time wasted watching it.
Let alone filming it.

OK
Final rewrite. I meant "...tje royalties she collects from writing twenty other novels.

And of course, as this entire endeavor can be characterized, it's "despicable", not dispicable". And by the way, The war seens were pathetic, especially the long shot a la Scorsese in "Goodfellas"

"Knocked Up" was more deserving of an Oscar. It was a more believable love story.

I don't know what world you people live in if you loved this movie. A group of spoiled aristocratic snobs believes a spoiled child, backs her up, ruins the guys life and the little ( to quote the movie) c### never has to answer for anything but the royalties she rights for twenty other novels?
Please.

Thanks for all the comments. I haven't seen this movie yet, however I've been waiting. I'm sure I will. I'm a big Jane fan.

i also think, for some reason, people think movies are outstanding and "beautiful pieces of work" if it flashes back and forth and there is atleast one "fucked up" character. they dont even care about the story line. what some may think is brilliant some may think is pointless.

zicky, the song played in during the movie's commercial is "Apologize" sang by One Republic ft. Timbaland. It's a beautiful song, perfect for this movie.

And Accord9, yes you are so right. This movie was robbed at the Academy's that it's almost ridiculous. It's hauntingly beautiful.

Amazing movie. ROBBED at Academy Awards. So SO much better than No Country for Old Men. Beautifully done, haunting. Has become one of my all time favorite films.

I've seen Titanic, but I'm excited to see this!

Although I have not read the book, I have just finished watching the movie, to be exact it just ended about 3 minutes ago. Atonement is.. well, is so well written it will lead you to cry because of its creativity. I believe this is most deffinately one of the best written movies I have ever had the pleasure of watching. It's a tragic love story that yet is based on love, gives so much more. It's creative how the different views of the characters give such life to the plot. The characters are wonderful and the actors that stepped into these rolls outdid themselves. Keira Knightly has grown on me so much since her "Bend It Like Beckham" days and won me over in Pride and Prejudice, I love that she's doing movie's like this, and James.. wow.. I had always thought he would be a one hit wonder but also has won me over. This movie is great for people who really get into movies, and watch every aspect. Not typically for the people who are into Vin Dysel, and Fast and Furious movies.. if you catch my drift.

All in all, I loved it and will think many more will also.

- Amanda
Age 16, Florida

I think that for some of the people who posted a comment, you really need to learn some grammar or at least take a typing class. For the people typing in Spanish on an English website, "NO ONE UNDERSTANDS WHAT YOUR SAYING!!!!!" For the person who wants Thai subtitles, ITS NEVER GOING TO HAPPEN!!!! And we will tell three six mafia that you say hi and want to be on their next cd. For one Keira Knightley is NOT in King Kong, that was Naomi Watts. And we are also very sorry to hear that Korea is fighting.....but i dont think it needs to be announced. For all you other extremely intelligent people out there, be safe and wear a helmet!!!!! hahaha

P.S. It was a good movie, not exactly what we expected, but still good!

i havent watched but have alot of interest to see it. it seems to be a lovely film.hoping to watch it soon.

This has to be the biggest pile of pants I have seen for god knows how long. Why some one would write such a load of miserable maudling depressing rubbish is beyond me, they should be writing for East Enders… Errr... get the impression I didn’t like it?

i want to second what Madison wrote. although i didn't see the film in theaters (i'm waiting for the DVD...4 more days) i have read the book, and i enjoyed it immensely, but i cried my eyes out, and it also made me feel strange, out of place, and as Madison and Briony, like no one understood why the book affected me the way it did. on a lighter note, James McAvoy is one of the most handsomest actors, and my favorite in this role. Kiera Knightley is amazing! Although i do think to fully grasp this movie, you must read the awesome book beforehand!

Can't wait until 3/18...

i love this movie this won of the best movis i have aver seen and the best movie kira knitley played in I LOVE KIRA KNITLEY!

I cannot wait t own it. Keira Knightley is my absolute favorite actress, and she looks wonderful in this movie! It is soooo sad and i cry when i hear the Title 'Atonement', it is simply brilliant. I think it is my favorite. Keira is kickbutt and James is great as well!!!! love love love

i like yall movies but i think hatchet is the best movie of the year and tell 3sixmafia that they song is tight and tell them to send me a neckalace to they know a hypinotize chain to jonestown miss pobox3438639 and give me a call to 16623584505 and tell me what you think about about me being on yall next show?

exellent

Film is amazing, Cinematography outstanding, acting fantastic, sounds even better, all i can say but what I want to know is whats the film (black and white) in the background where robbie finds himself during the war.

i haven't seen it yet but i would love to watch it once . ye,her accent is hard t0 listen. long film? i will try to stand it.

I hate it!!!!

i looovvvvvvvvvvvved this movie but it was sad at the end

I dooooooooooo wanna watch this movie.It looks cool!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! But they have spoilt Keira's beautiful face:-( and made her look anorexic

Glad it all worked out for you. Should I send a bill then?

I just finished watching the movie. If my friend hadn't told me to watch it, I would have turned it off well before the dinner scene. I thought it was very slow moving to start with. The flashbacks were confusing, the typing sounds in the background were disturbing, and the accents were hard to understand at times.The ending was also disappointing. I'm glad I didn't pay to see this in the movies.

I love, I love, I love this film, this is the best film of the year, se merecia el oscar no se porque no se lo dieron de hecho la academia tiene preferencias por las peliculas de su pais pero es increible como una pelicula tan buena como esta no este a la altura para los miembros, la verdad estoy muy triste por ATONEMENT todo en esta pelicula es fabuloso desde los actores, el director, el guion adaptado y la musica, se merecia ese oscar pero no te rindas joe se que esto es solo el comienzo de un sin fin de peliculas exitosas mucha suerte y buena vibra positiva desde Peru

This movie, Atonement is just amazing. It is one of the most moving, beautiful, intelligent movie I have seen in a long time. The acting between McAvoy and Knightely was amazing, they make it look so real, I almost had to tell myself that this was in fact a fictional movie, not a real one. The first time I saw it I did not unerstand all of it, but I could not stop thinking about it. I watched it again, and I was even more impressed. I would recommend this movie to everyone, but it is not a movie to watch if you are in for a light and uncomplicated movie. I would not say that this movie is pleasing, more disturbing, but in an incredible way. This movie shows how easily your life can be ruined, and how important it is to think about consequenses and separate fantasy and reality. Briony's imagination and what she actually sees are mixed and she ruins Robbie's and Cecilia's lives. The small mistakes in the world can be very grave in deed. The story is beautifully told, and I can promise eveyone who watces it, that in the end of the movie they will have tears in their eyes.

the most amazing film, but you have to get used to the unusual flashbacks, see it a second time to really appreciate its brillance. I had a little problem getting used to kiera knightley's clipped accent, very 30's i know, but difficult to adjust your ear to and i would have thought for the americans virtually impossible. I feel that it is a film that will go on to be a classic and one will wonder why it did not win in both the academy and oscar awards.

This movie is awesome!
I want to know what is the name of the movie that Robbie cried in the front of when he was in France, why Joe Wright chooses this old movie?
Anyway, I like this movie so much!

Atonement was a beautifully made film. Keira Knightley, James McAvoy, and Saiorse Ronan were excellent. I was most impressed with Saiorse Ronan. She looked mean. Ronan's character also had scary eyes.

I usually prefer the book version of a story to the movie adaptation, but this time it was the other way around. I got the book from the library last week and read it in a single day, and it was good but not riveting. But..... I just got home from the movie and that was amazing--even mesmerizing when compared to the book. I agree that some scenes were a bit long/odd--esp some of the war footage (okay, he's at war for a long time, we get it) and the freaky soldiers on the beach thing. However...move past that and look at the story as a whole. That typing over the music score made me jumpy!

joined by love ... separated by fear .. redeemed by hope .
simply awsom movie ... specially the suspene , the scenes which moves in past present at a same time ...
these things really ticks you to watch till end..
the most good thing is to realise of your mistake which you did somewhere in past.
good moral theme ...

Great movie, but I am wondering--was the redheaded cousin being raped in the woods, or knowingly sleeping with the chocolate guy? She was certainly coming on to him in a creepy, 13 year old way before this scene. Did she allow the encounter and then just go along that it was rape? (she does marry the guy later, after all)

i love this film very much and will aways. the best movie in my life is the lord of the rings,but now it's not certainly true,in opposit i was already be in loved this film though. in a film have beautyful and ablility actor, especially, a supporting actress, she has excellent acting, the best in me since i had watched, Althrough i now don't know her name yet. but she made me pleasure. no competition about it really.

JanetR -- Thanks soooo much. I haven't heard the whole song yet, but I'm in love with the tidbit I've heard.

I also can't believe that the Academy didn't recognize James McAvoy and Keira Knightley for their perfect performances! They both truly deserved nominations!

I LOVE this movie! It is so beautiful and moving. There are no words to describe the chemistry between James McAvoy and Keira Knightley. It absolutely infuriates me that neither one of them were nominated for an Oscar for their acting. I am really pulling through for this film to win Best Picture though!

ob--

The song is called "Apologize" and it's by One Republic, although the one in the commercial may be the remix done by Timbaland on his new CD.

Atonement was a gorgeous film, enough said.

Does anyone know the song that's played for the tv promo of this movie? It's a contemporary, slow song sung by a man (I think), and it sounds like he's saying, "It's too late...". The song doesn't seem to be on the soundtrack.

Thank you for that explanation. Yes, I can accept that the letter was retrieved from Cecelia's room, not from Bione's room.

Can you explain why the letter was not in an envelope when Brione handed it to Cecelia, what significance was the question Cecelia asked "Was there an envelope?" Bione had no envelope in her hand, yet when the letter is retrieved by Cecelia's room, it was in an envelope.

The thing about the envelope is puzzling to me and that is what suggested to me there could have been two typewritten letters (and I am not considering the hand-written letter by Robbie which he INTENDED to send). One letter (the sexually charged one) IN an envelope, and another letter (typed by Bione) without an envelope. I think the movie portrayed that the note being read by Cecelia was typed--so as to make it clear it was NOT the note handwritten by Robbie.

I need help. I am guessing that the 13-year sister DID NOT give the sexually explicit note to her older sister. Because it showed the original letter (in its envelope) in the 13-year old's drawer with her other letters and stuff -- when she retrieved it to give to the police.

No way, the older sister would have given the note back to her 13-year sister. So, I am assuming that the note that the 13-year gave to her sister was one which she had composed and typed on her t ypewriter, AS IF it were from the young man.

It must have been a powerfully person, tender, and loving letter -- because when Cecelia read it, she turned immediately to her sister and asked her if she had read it -- and also she asked if it came in an envelope. I am convinced that the note Cecelia read was NOT the crude note --

Instead of having to atone for an error in judgement, the young girl should be credited for writing such a beautiful love letter -- as to convince her sister that she was in love with Robby. Her letter got the two lovers together.

If she had not re-written the letter, the two people might not have EVER known they loved each other. The crude letter, had it be delivered to Cecelia, might have caused Cecelia to reject Robby.

Comments:

heaven help me, this was such grace :) the thing which added the most magic for me was finding (your finding, my enjoying) 2 actresses that could actually carry and build momentum in the two different times. how many times have moviemakers settled for look-alikes that parry with cardboard.

it was wonderful in editing as well, and screenplay-- leaving some things out. many intimate moments, but still a mystery after i'm done watching.

the scenery and shots were spectacular and made me feel visceral magic of nature (which i love so much)

at first i thought it would be a dry pedantic story of the rich, with the lovely, overwhelming estate--but far from it.

from the first scene, i identified with Brione--a skinny, overwrought girl too young to get a 'real boy'. i was that girl for so long ;) you made me jealous ;)

magic, i swear :) thanks to all of you who helped to make it.

thank you :)

The book and movie were amazing! my family did not like the movie because they didn't read the book, but i loved it. it put me into a very strange mood, i felt like no one understood me and i could never explain myself to anyone or how i felt. i felt, in short, like Briony.

P.S.- James McAvoy is now a hunk in my book!

Looks a good one but would love to see it

i think yall r great

Laura: Did you even watch it for every second of its beautiful unfolding story? It reminded me of a movie they would have made in the 1940s, no wonder they didn't talk a lot. It was more dramatic and suspenseful with less dialogue. For a two hour movie to unfold and explain the tragedy and truth two lovers had to go through while the background of a war with depth and pain took place...well, I don't understand how you could think it's boring. As for the characters; the love scene alone pulled many emotions of acting out of Kiera and McAvoy. It's eye opening and stunning.

It's been a long time since we have had a real story with much tenderness. Thank you.

the cinematogrpahy is worth watching this film. I'VE NEVER SEEN ANYTHING LIKE IT

this film is very interesting film, i love it keep it up.
its great to win an awards.

I loved this film, read the novel, and then saw the film again! Question, what happened to the atonement website?? I loved it but now you get redirected to this site instead? Please put the other site back up!

Thanks for everyone pointing out the problems with the Lifetime ad units. This has now been resolved. Enjoy the site!

I do not like this

i havent seen the movie im wating for it on dvd this add is bloking my games at mylifetime.com please who ever is responsible make it go away

I liked it alot , it made me cry uncontrollabley and then i made-out with my girlfriend because she was crying also, i really love this freakin movie !! yay go me !!

hello i like it

saw it 2x but i extremely bored in some scenes. There are some non essential scenes that must be deleted, like the kids scenes....

i'm sorry, but i'm disappointed :(

I really enjoyed this film I love the way you could relate to all the characters and to comparison to real life events, as well as actions. As soon as the film was over I went to borders and bought the book for those who have seen the film you prob. now why!

This movie is has touched me on many levels, I have watched it several times and I cry uncontrollably, especially during the scene at the Cafe and of course during the ending with Vanessa. Gripping and the soundtrack is fantastic and meshes well with the movie.

I loved this movie and would like to see it win some awards. Yeah, it won the Golden Globe for best picture, but the critics groups and guilds have ignored it. What up? I would say the best movies of the year are this, and There Will Be Blood, but No Country For Old Men seems to be the favorite, which I find reall surprising. It does not seem to be the overall acheivement of Atonement or There Will Be Blood. then ther is Juno, which is really cute, a fun screenplay, and Ellen Page is great - but hardly cinematic achievement.

I loved this movie and would like to see it win some awards. Yeah, it won the Golden Globe for best picture, but the critics groups and guilds have ignored it. What up? I would say the best movies of the year are this, and There Will Be Blood, but No Country For Old Men seems to be the favorite, which I find reall surprising. It does not seem to be the overall acheivement of Atonement or There Will Be Blood. then ther is Juno, which is really cute, a fun screenplay, and Ellen Page is great - but hardly cinematic achievement.

so impressed with the sound making harmony with the pictures. heartbreaking one-sided luv, beauiful framework of the story eveything was great!

This film is a true masterpiece and deserves every ounce of recognition that it is getting. I believe that it should have gotten way more awards especially for the actors, but just know that once seen, people tend to love it. I will definitely hope for an oscar and recommend that everyone experience this wonderfull work of art.

ps i love this film

pls move love film

its awesome !

Taut film. Great peformances. Handsome performers. Cinamentography is breathtaking. Artistic "picture" wonderful. What else? Great. I enjoyed your movie. Compelling....and a dose of Redgrave at the end! Brilliant. Casting right on. Interesting and on and on....Guys would like too. Hype is a period piece but is so much more.

fine

It was heart-wrenching and brilliantly filmed. It was so emotional that I'm not quite sure how to feel about it even now.

is so good yes-ok

Truly absorbing plot, fascinating photography, and superb acting. One of the best romantic war dramas that rates right up there with Titanic. See it.

shes a very pretty girl who has a nice career and plays in my very favorite movie king kong

hero and heroines both r beautiful includong their dressings and emotions showing in pictures.i did not see the movie

This was a fabulous film. i am routing for it to take home the oscar. Unfortunatley, i have my doubts about that happening.

omggg.
im DIEING to see this moivee :D
me&my boyfriend are gonna see it..
its looks so intrestinggg.
likee titanicc! :)

EVERYONE MUST SEE THIS MOVIE!
It is truly the most amazing and touching film I have ever seen...
It deserves to win every Oscar... Even the ones it was not nominated for! =)

la peli aun no se ha estrenado en Argentina, pero los avances han generado grandes expectativas

the movie is awesome,keep it up.

Loved this movie to death.

I forgot to add that the cast delivers stellar performances. I love this film.

i want to be sing up for the kids game makeover one

I loved this film - every little piece of it - but can someone tell me what is the last track that is played in the fil

The movie looks so interesting.I feel like watching but i donot know how and where to get from.